Skip to main content

Thanksgiving pies worth saving room for on your dessert table

Pie is often the part of Thanksgiving that people look forward to most, and a well-planned lineup makes dessert feel special. The Pioneer Woman put together twenty pie ideas for the holiday, ranging from classic fall flavors to fresh twists. Here is a practical look at the kinds of pies that list covers.

November 14, 2026 · From a story in The Pioneer Woman

The The Pioneer Woman headline beside the article's lead photo of a Thanksgiving pie spread
Screenshot: The Pioneer Woman, November 13, 2026.

Make the crust ahead

A go-to pie crust can be prepared early as part of a holiday cooking timeline. According to the article, this kind of dough freezes well. An all-butter crust, a cookie crust, or store-bought dough can also work, so planners have options based on their time and comfort in the kitchen.

Classic and new fillings

Pumpkin, apple, sweet potato, and pecan pies cover the traditional side of the table. For something different, the list includes maple syrup pie, cinnamon roll apple pie, and a chocolate pie with a cookie crust. Pears, cranberries, and a chess pie with a cornmeal crust also appear.

Pies for a crowd

Slab pies bake in a sheet pan, which makes it easier to serve many guests at once. A pumpkin version cut into squares and served with whipped cream is one example. The apple slab pie uses a buttery, flaky crust and a generous layer of spiced apples.

Make-ahead and no-bake options

Some desserts suit busy hosts. A no-bake cranberry pie needs no oven time, which helps with planning. Turtle pie can also be made ahead, and it uses pecans sparingly for a softer crunch.

Finishing touches

Toppings can change the feel of a pie. Warm slices can be served with hard sauce, whipped cream, or ice cream. A butter-pecan whipped cream can dress up a pumpkin pie, and salted whipped cream can finish a maple filling.

You pick the theme, the colors and the bites you love.